The Worst of the NFL This Season
What can I say? I'm a bad-news-first kind of woman. Here are the five things that put snakes in my stomach this NFL season:Peyton's Sunset - I've said it way too many times on this blog, usually to catastrophic jinxing effect, but it's really starting to look like Peyton Manning is nearing the end of his professional career. It feels almost like nit-picking to bring this up since the guy put up 4,700 yards and 39 TDs this season, but Manning has looked decidedly un-Manning-like for the last month or so. In December, he threw 3 TDs to 6 INTs with many a wounded duck and errant/sailing goose along the way. It's hard to see Denver getting back to the big dance in February without Manning performing at an immortal level. To play devil's advocate, he hasn't gotten much help from his banged up receivers while the Broncos have successfully transitioned to more of a ground-and-pound look that could serve them well in the playoffs. But assuming No. 18 is also dealing with some nagging injuries that will just get harder to recoup from as he gets older, we might be a month to a year away from his retirement. Whenever that happens, I'll miss his surgery against many a secondary, but I won't miss those Papa John's commercials one bit.
The San Francisco Axe - On a purely self-interested level, I am thrilled my team no longer has to deal with Jim Harbaugh's black magic in the NFC or the NFL at large. But I'm still totally stunned that the 49ers front office forced him out after he turned a miserable 3 - 13 team into a consistent winner instantaneously. The only thing that would make sense to me is if Harbaugh exerted a lot more leverage than San Francisco's front office could reasonably contend with. After all, when you've been to three straight NFC Championships and a Super Bowl, you can ask for just about anything or threaten to walk to the 50 or so pro and college teams that would welcome you with a parade and a mountain of cash. Sound familiar, Michigan fans? But Harbaugh's exit has been telegraphed since almost a year ago when the 49ers allegedly tried to trade him to Cleveland and let it leak. The front office has cited "philosophical differences" as the reason for his departure, but when your coach has had one of the winningest early careers in NFL history, I'm guessing Harbaugh's philosophy is a whole lot sounder than theirs, even if it's bat#@&* crazy. So now the eccentric khaki fiend will return to his alma mater and give San Francisco zero collateral to recover after their biggest loss since Steve Young retired. Welcome to the world of domineering, short-sided ownership, 49ers fans - I'm sure there are support groups in Dallas and DC that can hook you up.
The Broken, Reactionary Shield - Serious issues call for over-serious metaphors that Roger Goodell clings to. I wrote a bit earlier this year about the NFL's mishandling of high-profile domestic violence and sexual assault cases involving its players. Since that time, the league has taken some small [very ownership-friendly!] steps towards developing more consistent policies for player discipline and partnering with survivor support organizations. In a very utilitarian sense, it's better than nothing and brought much-needed attention to these issues. But I just cannot parse words in saying that I am embarrassed by the lack of integrity that Roger Goodell and many a league office exhibited leading up to this point, sweeping cases like Ray Rice's under the rug until public outrage and humiliation finally forced their hands. Between this and the league's long-standing denial of player health issues like CTE, I can no longer fool myself into thinking I do not implicitly support a very unethical organization when I watch games, play fantasy football or blog here. If I have a sliver of hope that some things will get better, it's because public accountability [or the associated ad revenue lost] can force change, but if it takes drastic singular events with clear video evidence every time, don't expect much else to change.
The Best of the NFL This Season
No amount of heroics on the field can atone for the much darker side of the NFL this season [and many unchecked seasons prior], but here's a few bright spots that I enjoyed during a turbulent time within and outside of the world of football:The Bills and Cardinals Being Better Than You Thought - Most of the old standbys like the Pats, Broncos, Packers and Seahawks did just fine this season, but there were also some delightful surprises from several teams that have been miserable for years and/or expected to crash and burn this year. Although they needed a meaningless Week 17 game to do it, the Bills finally got their first winning season in a decade despite losing Kiko Alonso and Jarius Byrd before the season started and having to trust in E.J. Manuel/Kyle Orton at quarterback. Orton had a solid performance to carry the offense, but Buffalo owes its winning ways to an outstanding defense that led the league in sacks and ranked in the top five for points and yards allowed. Heck, you have the Bills to thank if Aaron Rodgers doesn't get the MVP - he was a given until Buffalo held him to less than 200 yards, no TDs and 2 INTs. It's a shame these guys didn't make the playoffs, but if they can figure out a couple more things on offense, who knows what they might do next year. I won't spend as much time on the Cardinals here since we'll get to see them again this weekend, but they've been a lesson in resilience all year long with a litany of injuries and tough opponents. They've gone 11 - 5 and nearly locked up a very competitive division, but they'll probably still be underdogs in Carolina this weekend, and I'm guessing that's how Bruce Arians likes it.
Odell Beckham, Poetry in Motion - What can I say about rookie phenom Odell Beckham Jr. that hasn't already been said elsewhere in recent weeks? He averaged the most yards-per-game of any wide receiver this season and ranked in the top 10 for yards and TDs despite missing the first four games of the season. This past draft was loaded with receiving talent including Mike Evans, Sammy Watkins, Kelvin Benjamin and Brandin Cooks, but OBJ snatched the spotlight with the catch seen 'round the world and never gave us a reason to turn away. Not only is he massively productive--and perhaps single-handedly saving Eli Manning's career--he has an extraordinary level of athletic talent that we haven't seen since Randy Moss or maybe ever. There's no doubt a new star has been born and he's a lock for Rookie of the Year.
J.J. Watt, Our Spiritual MVP - I may be wrong and J.J. Watt may have a real shot at MVP honors this season, but with the Texans missing the playoffs and voters having significant biases toward quarterbacks and offensive players in general, it's a loooong shot. Since I'm not part of the Skull and Bones society that gets to vote [insipidly] on these things, I'm dedicating this corner to the hardest working defensive lineman in the league and the real MVP this season. Mr. Watt's resume for your consideration: 1) recorded at least one sack or turnover in 15 out of 16 games this season; 2) had 20+ sacks for the second time in his career (an NFL first) including a safety; 3) led the NFL in QB hits and pressures; 4) had seven turnovers including a blocked field goal, an interception and five forced fumbles; 5) scored five TDs, two of those on defense. If this guy can't earn an MVP after a season like that--truly unlike any other performance for any position in the NFL--then they really should just rename the thing "Most Valuable Quarterback."
JLotz's Self-Aggrandizing Corner
I put this section last because you probably won't care, and that is perfectly fine - go buy illegal fireworks and black eyed peas or something! But outside of the Saints' 2014 Misery Tour, I had a pretty good season of blogging and other football extracurriculars. In terms of the weekly picks, I closed out the season at a respectable 175-80-1 and my best hit rate since starting this blog (68%). That's as good or better than all but three guys at ESPN and all but one guy at CBS. My preseason win-loss predictions were a bit more hit-and-miss. I got a personal-best seven teams' win totals exactly right (Panthers, Packers, Rams, Raiders, Steelers, Patriots, Dolphins), 44% of teams within one win and 72% of teams within two wins. But I whiffed by 3 or more wins with nine teams, mostly because of the confounding NFC South and NFC North.In other self-referential news, my silly fantasy football team (Bakery Special) won the league championship this past weekend! It wasn't a pretty game given that my opponent and I started Peyton Manning and Matt Ryan, respectively, but I closed out the season on a 6-game win streak to go 12-5 on the year and get great satisfaction out of a very arbitrary pastime that usually makes me grind my teeth for days when I bench the wrong guy. Here's to you, my championship starters:
- Matt Ryan (QB)
- Alfred Morris (RB), Jeremy Hill (RB)
- Odell Beckham (WR), Mike Evans (WR), Alshon Jeffery (WR)
- Martellus Bennett (TE)
- Justin Tucker (K)
- Texans D/ST - Or really, just J.J. Watt
- Ben Roethlisberger (QB)
- Isaiah Crowell (RB), Chris Ivory (RB), Matt Asiata (RB)
- Mike Wallace (WR)
- Scott Chandler (TE), Kyle Rudolph (TE)
- Eagles D/ST - Or really, just Darren Sproles sometimes













